CARROT Weather's personality is fun, but the subscription price has users questioning whether a weather app needs to cost $20/year. These alternatives deliver great forecasts for free.
Each app below addresses a specific gap in CARROT Weather's offering. We picked them based on real user review patterns and feature differentiation.
Apple Weather incorporated Dark Sky's hyperlocal precipitation data and provides detailed forecasts, radar, air quality, and severe weather alerts for free. For most iPhone users, the built-in app now covers everything they need without installing anything additional.
Explore Apple Weather data →Weather Underground aggregates data from hundreds of thousands of personal weather stations for the most hyperlocal conditions available. The station map shows exactly where data comes from, and community contributions create unmatched granularity in local conditions.
Explore Weather Underground data →Windy provides the most visually impressive weather maps and forecasts available, with animated wind, precipitation, temperature, and wave visualizations. Multiple model comparisons (GFS, ECMWF, etc.) let you evaluate different forecast sources for better accuracy.
Explore Windy data →AccuWeather's MinuteCast predicts precipitation minute by minute for the next two hours. RealFeel temperature accounts for humidity, wind, and sun intensity. The 15-day forecasts and severe weather alerts provide comprehensive planning information.
Explore AccuWeather data →WeatherKit is Apple's weather data API that powers Apple Weather and enables developers to build custom weather experiences. For developers and technical users, it provides access to the same high-quality data that made Dark Sky famous.
Explore WeatherKit data →Yr is provided free by the Norwegian Meteorological Institute with no ads and no subscriptions. Known for excellent accuracy, especially in Europe, it offers detailed forecasts, precipitation graphs, and aurora forecasts. The clean, no-nonsense interface focuses purely on weather data.
Explore Yr data →We compared weather apps on forecast accuracy, feature depth, pricing value, and data sources to find the best CARROT Weather alternatives.
The humor is fun but the weather data comes from the same sources available in free apps. Apple Weather now includes much of what made CARROT special (Dark Sky data). The subscription is mainly justified if you love the personality and want cross-platform or Apple Watch complications.
Accuracy varies by location. Apple Weather inherited Dark Sky's excellent US precipitation data. AccuWeather's MinuteCast is strong for short-term rain predictions. Weather Underground's personal stations provide the most local data. Comparing multiple apps for your specific location is the best approach.
Apple acquired Dark Sky in 2020 and shut down the app in 2023. The hyperlocal precipitation data was integrated into Apple Weather, and the API was replaced by WeatherKit. Apple Weather is essentially Dark Sky's spiritual successor.
Yes, Apple Weather is free and uses the same data sources. Yr is completely free with no ads from the Norwegian weather service. Weather Underground is free with minimal ads. Windy is free for basic use. Compare weather apps on AppVulture to find the best forecast for your location.
Messaging and Communication alternatives.
Photo and Video - Photo Editing alternatives.
Health & Fitness alternatives.
Productivity - Calendar alternatives.